Back to quiz
Score 4–6 · Curious

You're indy-curious. Let's explore the evidence.

You're open to the arguments. Here's a balanced, evidence-based guide to why many people in Wales support independence. Every claim is sourced and linked.

Open-minded approachBalanced evidenceInternational examplesSource-cited
The Evidence
01

Why Do People Support Welsh Independence?

Wales is a distinct nation with its own language, culture, history, and identity. Many supporters argue that self-governance is a democratic right — that decisions affecting Wales should be made by people in Wales, accountable to Welsh voters. Others are motivated by economic arguments: that Wales's potential is being held back by a system designed for a much larger, more centralised state. The Welsh independence movement is diverse: it includes people motivated by democracy, culture, economics, and a simple belief that the people of Wales are best placed to govern themselves.

02

The Economic Argument

Wales has significant natural assets: renewable energy (onshore and offshore wind, tidal, hydro), water resources, tourism, and a skilled workforce. Under the current constitutional settlement, revenues from these assets often flow to Westminster. An independent Wales could retain and reinvest these revenues. The Independent Commission on the Constitutional Future of Wales (2024) found Wales has significant untapped energy potential — including offshore wind and tidal power. Small nations with similar resource profiles — Ireland, Iceland, Denmark, Norway — consistently outperform larger neighbours on economic indicators. The "Flotilla Effect" research (Harvard Kennedy School) found small EU nations grew faster than large ones over 13 years, closing the GDP per capita gap by almost two-thirds.

03

The Democratic Argument

Wales has voted differently from England in most UK general elections since 1979, yet has been governed by parties it didn't vote for. The Senedd has limited powers — key decisions on taxation, welfare, energy policy, and foreign affairs are made at Westminster. Independence would mean Welsh voters always get the government they vote for, with full democratic accountability. In May 2026, Plaid Cymru became the largest party in the Senedd with 43 seats, and Rhun ap Iorwerth was elected First Minister — a significant milestone in Welsh democratic history.

04

Cultural and Language Arguments

Welsh is one of Europe's oldest living languages, spoken by around 900,000 people. The Welsh Government has set a target of 1 million Welsh speakers by 2050. Independence supporters argue that full self-governance would better protect and promote the Welsh language and culture — giving Wales control over education, broadcasting, and cultural policy without Westminster constraints. Comparable small nations — Iceland, the Faroe Islands — demonstrate that small nations can be powerful custodians of minority languages. The Welsh language is not just a cultural artefact; it is a living community language that defines Wales as a distinct nation.

05

International Examples of Successful Small Nations

Wales (population ~3.2 million) is not unusually small for an independent nation. Here are comparable examples:

🇮🇪

Ireland

Population: 5.1 million

GDP per capita ~$100,000+

Joined EU 1973. Transformed from agricultural economy to tech and pharma hub. Now one of Europe's wealthiest nations.

🇮🇸

Iceland

Population: 370,000

Top global rankings for happiness

Highly developed economy. Manages own fisheries, geothermal energy, and foreign policy independently.

🇳🇴

Norway

Population: 5.4 million

Sovereign wealth fund: $1.7 trillion

Consistently top of UN Human Development Index. Controls North Sea oil revenues through the Norwegian Government Pension Fund.

🇩🇰

Denmark

Population: 5.9 million

World's happiest nation (multiple years)

Consistently ranked among the most prosperous and happy nations. Strong welfare state, high wages.

🇪🇪

Estonia

Population: 1.3 million

Digital democracy pioneer

Transformed from Soviet republic to digital democracy and EU/NATO member in 30 years. E-governance world leader.

06

Common Concerns and Balanced Responses

"Wales can't afford it"

The fiscal deficit reflects current policy choices, not fixed economic reality. Ireland had similar concerns before independence and is now one of Europe's wealthiest nations. The deficit includes reserved spending Wales cannot control.

"We'd lose the NHS"

NHS Wales is already devolved and has been run independently since 1999. An independent Wales would continue to run its own health service — this is already the case.

"What about the border?"

The UK–Ireland relationship demonstrates that two independent nations can maintain open borders and deep trade ties. Geography doesn't change with constitutional status.

"It would take years"

Scotland's independence referendum showed a detailed transition plan can be developed. Independence is a managed process, not an overnight change. The question is whether to start the journey.

Ready to explore further?

If the evidence has moved you, explore the supporter guide — or browse the full resources directory.